Fluffernutter Cookies, First Attempt…

It’s another day of starring at the pantry wondering, “What can I bake in here?”

I noticed a bag of mini marshmellows. So, I searched for marshmellow cookie recipes. The search yielded a lot of chocolate and marshmellow cookies. Sadly, I only had Hershey Cocoa Powder.

Feeling defeated, I resumed my search. Surprisingly, I found a Fluffernutter Cookies. The marshmellow peanut butter cookie recipe is available at Dessert Now Dinner Later.

In the past, I use to glance at a recipe’s ingredients and ignore the instructions. I’m glad I stopped doing that, because Fluffernutter Cookies call for frozen marshmellows. If you don’t have frozen marshmellows, Amber Brady suggest freezing 1 cup of marshmellows for 1 to 2 hours.

Besides baking with frozen marshmellows, I decided to add salt too. Growing up, I was taught not to bake with it. In the spirit of trying out a new recipe. I decided try baking with salt. The result was…fluffernutter

My cookies came out colossus. My cookie scooper was probably to big. Also. I did not try to reshape them like Amber suggested. They taste like fluffernutters. Plus, my kids liked them.

Although they came out a bit flat, these are very soft cookies. Definitely grease the spatula for each cookie transfer. Otherwise, they’ll start falling a part.

For a first attempt, they came out pretty good. It was supposed to make 20 cookies, but I made 14. To be fair, my first batch was to big. Most of the marshmellows melted. I think I baked them too long. Below was the closest I got to Brenda’s cookies.

I wouldn’t bring this batch to a cookie exchange, but I would make them for my family again. Next time, I’ll chill the dough for a bit. It may help keep the scoops smaller.

If you’re curious. They were supposed to look like this…😅

Fluffernutter Cookies from Dessert Now Dinner Later

2 thoughts on “Fluffernutter Cookies, First Attempt…

Add yours

Sharing is caring! Let me know what you think.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Up ↑

Little Miss Mindful

Lifestyle | Self Care | Intentional Living

Dark Roast Magazine

DarkRoast Magazine is an exclusive wellness, connection and regulation magazine. We focus on health, realistic tools for emotional regulation and recovery, the importance of wellness, and connectivity. Take five and enjoy

Merry of August

Lifestyle Blog

Bournemouth Girl

Planning the life you want

A Sustainably Simple Life

Living sustainably on a budget

Twirling Book Princess

Twirling Through Books Daily

Mornings on Macedonia

DIY, Decor, & More


Positivity and motivation.

The Wellbeing Blogger

Helping you make Art with Life, one life project at a time

%d bloggers like this: